Hard enamel and soft enamel are two methods of adding colour to recessed metal detail on awards and pins; hard enamel is filled and polished flush with the metal for a smooth, jewellery like surface, while soft enamel leaves the colour recessed below the raised metal lines, creating a textured, dimensional finish. Both produce vivid, durable colour and both have a rightful place in premium award making. The choice between them is not about one being superior, but about matching the finish to the design, the desired feel, and the intended impression. Understanding the honest trade offs helps you specify exactly the right result.
How enamel colouring works
Both techniques start the same way. A metal piece is produced with recessed areas, or wells, defined by raised metal lines that form the outline of the artwork. These wells are then filled with coloured enamel or resin. The fundamental difference lies in what happens next and how much enamel is applied relative to the metal lines.
In hard enamel, the wells are slightly overfilled, cured, and then polished back so that the enamel sits perfectly flush with the raised metal. The whole surface becomes smooth and level, with colour and metal on the same plane. In soft enamel, the wells are filled to just below the height of the metal lines and left there, so the raised metal stands proud of the recessed colour, giving a surface you can feel with a fingertip.
Hard enamel: the smooth, premium option
Hard enamel is prized for its smooth, refined, jewellery like quality. Because the surface is polished flush, it feels seamless to the touch and reflects light evenly across colour and metal alike. This gives hard enamel pieces a substantial, high end presence that suits prestigious awards and luxury brand recognition. The polishing process also tends to make the metal lines appear crisp and bright.
The finish is extremely durable. With colour and metal on the same level, there are no raised edges to catch or wear, and the surface resists scratching well. Hard enamel is more labour intensive to produce, because the filling, curing, and polishing stages require care and precision, and this is reflected in its position as the more premium of the two options. For a flagship award where the tactile smoothness and refined appearance matter, hard enamel is often the natural choice.
Soft enamel: the textured, detailed option
Soft enamel offers its own distinct advantages. Because the colour sits recessed below the raised metal lines, the finished piece has a pleasing dimensional texture. You can feel the ridges of the metal outlines, which gives soft enamel a tactile, crafted quality that many people find appealing. The raised metal lines also stand out clearly, which can make intricate detail and fine outlines especially crisp.
Soft enamel handles complex, detailed artwork very well and is more economical to produce than hard enamel, making it an excellent choice for larger quantities or designs with fine intricacy. It is often finished with a protective epoxy or clear coat to add durability and a subtle sheen. While the recessed colour is very durable, the raised metal edges are slightly more exposed than in a flush hard enamel surface, though under normal display conditions this is rarely a concern.
An honest side by side comparison
- Surface feel: Hard enamel is smooth and flush; soft enamel is textured with raised metal lines.
- Appearance: Hard enamel looks refined and jewellery like; soft enamel looks dimensional and crafted.
- Detail handling: Both handle detail well, though soft enamel can emphasise fine outlines especially crisply.
- Durability: Both are durable; hard enamel has no raised edges to wear, while soft enamel is often sealed for protection.
- Cost and lead time: Soft enamel is generally more economical; hard enamel involves more labour and sits at a higher investment.
Neither finish is objectively better. Hard enamel leans toward smooth luxury and premium feel, while soft enamel offers tactile dimension, crisp detail, and value. The right answer depends entirely on the character you want the award to project.
Choosing between them for your award
When advising clients, we start with the intended impression. If the goal is a smooth, weighty, luxury object that feels like fine jewellery, hard enamel is usually the answer. If the goal is a detailed, characterful piece with tactile texture, or if quantity and budget are important considerations, soft enamel is an excellent and honest choice. The colours in both are equally vivid, so this is genuinely a decision about finish and feel rather than colour quality.
Both techniques integrate naturally with the base metal finish. Enamel detail can sit within a brushed, polished, or plated surface, and the surrounding metal treatment strongly influences the overall look. We consider the enamel method and the metal finish together to achieve a cohesive result.
Enamel within a larger award design
Enamel is rarely the whole story of an award; it is usually a coloured accent within a broader design. A hard enamel brand emblem might sit on a mirror polished body, or a soft enamel crest might feature on a machined metal plate mounted to an acrylic form. Within our custom trophy service, enamel detail frequently provides the pop of brand colour that ties a piece to a company identity, set against complementary finishes and materials.
Durability and care
Both hard and soft enamel are durable finishes suited to a lifetime of display. Hard enamel’s flush surface is exceptionally resistant to wear, while soft enamel’s protective coating guards its recessed colour and raised lines. For both, gentle cleaning with a soft cloth is all that is needed, and abrasive cleaners should be avoided. Displayed indoors and handled with normal care, an enamelled award keeps its vivid colour and detail for many years.
Frequently asked questions
Which is more durable, hard or soft enamel? Both are durable. Hard enamel’s flush surface has no raised edges to wear, while soft enamel is typically sealed with a protective coating. For display awards, both perform excellently.
Is hard enamel always the better choice? No. Hard enamel offers a smooth premium feel, but soft enamel provides tactile dimension, crisp detail, and better value. The best choice depends on your design and goals.
Are the colours different between the two? The colour vibrancy is comparable in both. The difference is in surface texture and feel, not colour quality.
How do I decide for my award? Share your design through our online design tool and we will advise on the best enamel method. We respond within 24 hours and deliver worldwide.
Related terms
